Monthly Lecture
This event has taken place
From Contradiction to Decision: Applying Paraconsistent Logics in Futures Studies
Javad Beigi (Independent researcher)
Abstract
A basic challenge in futures studies is dealing with contradictory evidence and assessments which, though analytically important, may lead ordinary decision-making and scenario-building processes to discard data, oversimplify the problem, or struggle to assess the consistency of future options. The central question is how to use the informational content of conflicting evidence for analysing future situations and supporting decisions, without discarding it. Focusing on paraconsistent logics, in particular the paraconsistent annotated evidential logic Eτ, this talk formulates an approach in which contradiction is not an unavoidable obstacle to reasoning but a state that can be represented and analysed.
The practical innovation of this approach is to move paraconsistent logic from theoretical debates about contradiction to the practical analysis of evidence and decision support in futures studies. In this framework, the evidence for and against a proposition is retained, and annotated values are used to assess its epistemic status in terms of confirmation, refutation, conflicting evidence and lack of sufficient evidence. Instead of imposing consistency on the data by removing inconsistent evidence, one can thus expose the structure of contradictions, assess the intensity and pattern of conflicting evidence, and use the results when comparing and formulating future scenarios. This makes it possible to design a process in which contradictions in expert assessments, environmental trends and drivers of change are examined systematically before they become the basis for decisions.
The talk sets out the logical foundations of this approach and sketches a path for putting it into practice in scenario building, a path in which retaining conflicting information, analysing the epistemic status of evidence and avoiding unjustified inferences from contradiction can help develop analytical tools for decision-making under complexity and uncertainty. The main proposal is that, instead of trying to remove contradiction from futures studies, we can turn it into an object of logical analysis and a potential resource for enriching scenarios.
Date: Monday, 19 October 2026
Time: 16:00–17:30 (Tehran time)
Format: Hybrid (in person and online)
Address: Room 311, Pure Mathematics Group, Faculty of Mathematics and Computer Science, Amirkabir University of Technology (north gate, Rasht Street, off Hafez Street), Tehran
Audio and video
Full video of the lecture
This lecture was held on 26 October 2026.