Monthly Lecture

This event has taken place

The Problem of Change and the Logic LP

Kasra Farsian (PhD in philosophical logic, Tarbiat Modares University)

Abstract

“The ordinary objects around us change over time, yet remain the same object they were before the change.” If Socrates takes his motorcycle to the garage and has the front tyre replaced, he seems quite sure that the motorcycle he rides home is the same one as before, indeed the very motorcycle Aristophanes gave him seven years ago. The example shows that our ordinary intuition accepts that objects which lose some of their properties or parts, or have them replaced, remain the same objects. But how much of Socrates' motorcycle can change while we still accept that it is the same motorcycle? One per cent? Half of its parts, or a quarter? In this talk I present a version of the sorites paradox related to the metaphysical problem of change and the persistence of material objects, and argue that standard logic (first-order logic with identity, and second-order logic) forces us into a sequence of unwelcome conclusions, including that even if every part of Socrates' motorcycle is replaced, it is still the motorcycle of the first day. In the second part I explain how such conclusions can be avoided, through a reinterpretation of the problem of change and a second-order version of LP. As a non-standard logic, second-order LP offers resources that invalidate the sorites argument; the most important of these is the non-standard behaviour of identity, which is the key to stopping the paradox of Socrates' motorcycle.

Date: Monday, 21 September 2026

Time: 16:00–17:30 (Tehran time)

Format: Hybrid (in person and online)

Address: Iranian Institute of Philosophy, No. 4, Shahid Arakelian Alley, Neauphle-le-Château Street, Tehran

Join the online session

Audio and video

Full audio of the lecture

This lecture was held on 7 November 2026.