Monthly Lecture
In collaboration with the Institute for Research in Fundamental Sciences (IPM), Isfahan Branch
This event has taken place
Deontic Justification Logics: Resolving Moral Conflicts and Paradoxes with Normative Reasons
Meghdad Ghari (Isfahan University of Technology)
Abstract
In everyday life we deal with various norms, that is, rules stating which actions are obligatory, permitted or forbidden. For example, the laws of a country, the precepts of a religion, traffic rules, the rules of a game and the grammatical rules of a language all contain norms. In the 1950s a formal logic for studying moral and normative notions (such as “obligatory”, “permitted”, “forbidden”, etc.) was introduced, which became known as standard deontic logic. It soon became clear that this logic faces many paradoxes, for example Plato's dilemma of conflicting obligations, the paradox of epistemic obligation, and the Good Samaritan paradox. Many deontic logics have since been introduced to resolve these paradoxes, but none of them states the “reason” for an action being obligatory or permitted. The justification or reason on the basis of which an agent is obliged or permitted to perform an action is called a “normative reason”. Justification logics allow us to express normative reasons in the language of formal logic. In this talk we show how using normative reasons in justification logics helps us resolve some of these paradoxes. In addition to the paradoxes mentioned above, we discuss Protagoras' court paradox and offer a solution to it in justification logic.
Date: Monday, 8 July 2024
Time: 17:00–19:00 (Tehran time)
Format: Hybrid (in person and online)
Venue: Isfahan, Azadi Square, University of Isfahan Guest House, first floor
Audio and video files
Lecture announcement (PDF)